On an older Westchester house the stucco surface was part of the architecture. Mediterranean, Arts and Crafts and Colonial Revival houses each tended toward their own kind of texture, and many have since been refinished in something that suits none of them.
The county’s older houses were built in a range of styles, and the stucco on them was chosen as part of the design. A Mediterranean house was often finished by hand with a soft, irregular surface. An Arts and Crafts house often carried a rough, stone-studded one. A Colonial Revival house in stucco tended toward something plain and even.
As a textured stucco finishes contractor in Westchester we start with the style of the house rather than with the surface currently on it. Plenty of these houses were refinished decades ago in a uniform texture that had nothing to do with their architecture, and reproducing that faithfully keeps the mistake going. The better question is what the house was meant to look like.
Four things that follow from texture being part of the design.
Westchester’s period houses were not finished at random. Hand-worked surfaces, rough stone-studded ones and plain even ones each tended to belong to particular styles, and the texture was chosen alongside the roofline and the windows.
Over the decades a lot of Westchester period houses were resurfaced, often in a uniform finish that was quicker to apply than the original. The house kept its shape and lost part of its character in the process.
If the surface on the wall today is a later replacement, reproducing it exactly preserves the error. On a Westchester period house the texture currently there is evidence to consider, not an instruction to follow.
When the surface suits the style again, the architecture reads as it was meant to. Owners often notice the difference before they can say what changed.
Roofline, windows, entrance and overall shape usually settle it quickly. On a Westchester period house that identification tells us what kind of surface the house was designed to carry.
Old photographs, earlier sales listings and the owner's own records often show the Westchester house as first finished. Where the current texture differs from what the evidence shows, that difference becomes part of the conversation.
With the style and the evidence in hand, we propose the surface that suits the house, and explain plainly where it differs from what is on the wall now. The owner decides, knowing what each option means for the architecture.
The safe-sounding instruction is to put back exactly what is there, and on many Westchester houses it is the wrong one. What is there may be the third finish the house has worn, applied in a hurry by someone who never considered what the architecture wanted. A refinish is the one moment the surface can be put right. Before agreeing a texture, ask what style the house is and what it would originally have carried. If the person quoting has not looked beyond the current wall, the finish will be accurate to the mistake rather than to the house.
Period houses in a range of styles fill Scarsdale, Bronxville, Larchmont and Rye, with more through New Rochelle and Mamaroneck, and the same question about the right surface applies across them.
See stucco contractor Westchester for our other stucco work in the county, or textured stucco finishes NYC for the main finish types and how each one ages.
Browse our gallery to explore the outstanding projects we’ve successfully completed, highlighting our expertise.
Usually a hand-worked surface with soft, irregular variation rather than a crisp, uniform grain. On a Mediterranean style house in Westchester, a finish that looks too even or machine-perfect tends to fight the architecture. Old photographs of the house are the best guide to what it originally carried.
Old photographs, earlier sales listings and your own records are the best evidence. They often show the house as first finished, before any later refinish. Comparing that evidence with what is on the Westchester wall today shows whether the current surface belongs to the house or replaced it.
Not automatically. If the current surface is original or suits the style, copying it is right. If it replaced something that belonged to the architecture, copying it preserves the mistake. On a Westchester period house it is worth checking which of those applies before the texture is agreed.
Often because it was refinished at some point in a quick, even texture that replaced a hand-worked original. The house keeps its shape but loses some of its character. A refinish in a surface that suits its style is usually what brings a Westchester period house back into focus.
More than most owners expect. The surface covers most of what anyone sees, so a texture that suits the style makes the architecture read clearly, and one that does not makes a well designed Westchester house look vaguely wrong without anyone being able to say why.
